National

Graded measures, not knee-jerk reactions needed against air pollution

Agency | November 14, 2017 05:08 PM

NEW DELHI: "Delhi is a wakeup call for the world on air pollution. It clearly tells us that unless decisive actions are taken to reduce air pollution, the events we are witnessing in Delhi over the past week are likely to be increasingly common." Unicef released this statement last year when thick smog blanketed the National Capital Region, choking millions.

The state of health emergency stirred the public discourse on air pollution in the country. Apart from knee-jerk measures that included Delhi government's odd-even scheme, halting construction activities and shutting down schools, a graded response system was put in place by the Supreme Court. It was believed to be a big step towards addressing the pollution issues as for the first time a legal framework for coordination among Delhi's various pollution controlling agencies and its neighbouring states was put in place.

Sadly, the citizens residing in north India, especially in the National Capital Region woke up again enveloped with the smog. A public health emergency has been declared and the policymakers are resorting to the same measures as last year. Solutions like traffic rationing, banning sale of Diwali crackers and shutting down power plants are well-intentioned but India's struggle against air pollution is a deeper problem that requires more than these ad-hoc solutions.

There are severe issues in the approach that is being used to tackle the air pollution crisis.

First, ad hoc solutions might be quick at lowering pollution levels but since they don't address the root cause, they can't do anything once the ban is lifted. The seasonal problem of severe air pollution in Delhi is a result of the stubble burn by farmers in the neighbouring states. The farmers are too poor to clear their field for replanting by less polluting means. A long-term solution that can equip farmers needs to be put in place to tackle this spiralling crisis.

Second, there are issues with the graded response system as well. The air quality index method used is very misleading as the nomenclatures vary within countries. The following fact puts this perspective. It is claimed that since the launch of a graded response action plan, there has not been a single day when air pollution in the national capital reached severe levels. But what is termed as moderate in Indian cities is a red alert situation in other countries. For instance, moderate to poor is the air quality when particulate matter 2.5 is between 61-90 µg/m3 while 70 µg/m3 for London is a high alert situation.

Third, air pollution is a persistent problem in India. It is neither restricted to Delhi nor to this season. Apart from severe air pollution levels that are observed during the months of October and November, there are days when air quality is recorded to be very poor or poor. In 2016, very poor air quality was recorded for 64 days in Delhi.

A state-level study of Indian states -- Social Progress Index -- depicted a negative relationship between economic development and environmental quality as well as health and wellness. The state scores shed light on the severe environmental conditions prevalent in the country. Delhi's scores are among the lowest in both the parameters. At the global level, a study by WHO last year termed Delhi as the megacity with worst air quality. The list of 20 most polluted cities included three Indian cities -- Gwalior, Allahabad and Raipur. Therefore, it becomes important to find solutions that tackle the problem holistically and not just cater to the seasonal issues.

Fourth, the debate revolves around the health hazards that are being caused by air pollution and we clearly ignore the fact that air pollution is not only a health risk but also an economic burden. Pollution causes illness and premature death that leads to reduction in life expectancy and a loss of productive labour. This reduces output and incomes levels. Over the years, India has suffered heavy economic losses due to such absurd levels of air pollution.According to a 2013 World Bank study, India incurred the highest losses in the world in terms of labour output caused by air pollution. In terms of welfare losses India lost 7.69 percent of GDP due to air pollution.

A panacea for India's air quality woes requires that debate is tilted towards the economic losses that the country is facing due to escalating air pollution and a holistic action plan that focusses on real solutions targeting the problem rather than knee-jerk policies.

 

(Amit KAPOOR is chair, Institute for Competitiveness. The views expressed are personal. He can be contacted at amit.kapoor@competitiveness.in and tweets @kautiliya. Manisha Kapoor, senior researcher, Institute for Competitiveness has contributed to the article)

Have something to say? Post your comment
Must Read
Twinkle Khanna speaks at UN women's entrepreneurship summit
Twinkle Khanna speaks at UN women's entrepreneurship summit
Delhi University needs to adapt to changing trends in higher education: President
Delhi University needs to adapt to changing trends in higher education: President
27 universities honored Mahamahopadhyaya Swami Bhadreshdasji  at the Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda
27 universities honored Mahamahopadhyaya Swami Bhadreshdasji at the Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda
Bikram Majithia flays congress Minister  Navjot Sidhu for putting pressure on CM  for his trial in a drug mafia scam
Bikram Majithia flays congress Minister Navjot Sidhu for putting pressure on CM for his trial in a drug mafia scam
Computer brain training may cut dementia risk by 29%
Computer brain training may cut dementia risk by 29%
Bhutia offers training stint to Kashmiri youth Majid Khan
Bhutia offers training stint to Kashmiri youth Majid Khan
'Aashiqui' fame actor Rahul Roy joins BJP
'Aashiqui' fame actor Rahul Roy joins BJP
Three held guilty in Kopardi gang rape-murder that rocked Maharashtra
Three held guilty in Kopardi gang rape-murder that rocked Maharashtra
'Padmavati' makers knew paper work was incomplete: CBFC chief Prasoon Joshi
'Padmavati' makers knew paper work was incomplete: CBFC chief Prasoon Joshi
PM seeks ideas for Mann Ki Baat on Nov 26
PM seeks ideas for Mann Ki Baat on Nov 26
Nurmahal suicides; Police yet to begin re-investigation
Nurmahal suicides; Police yet to begin re-investigation
Sukhbir Badal announces new team of district presidents of SAD
Sukhbir Badal announces new team of district presidents of SAD